The BEST Cinnamon Cookies

The BEST Cinnamon Cookies (Double Batch): Your New Comfort Food Obsession

Hey friends, Mason here! Can we talk about magic for a sec? Not the wand-waving kind – the kind that happens when butter, sugar, and cinnamon collide in your oven. Picture this: cookies with golden, crisp edges giving way to pillowy-soft centers swirled with molten cinnamon filling. They’re like if a cinnamon roll and your favorite chewy sugar cookie had a deliciously irresistible baby. That’s exactly what you’re getting with these Double Batch Cinnamon Cookies – and trust me, you’ll want every last one of those 48 glorious cookies. Why a double batch? Because these beauties vanish faster than my willpower near a warm cookie tray. They’re weeknight warriors (yes, even after a crazy day!), weekend gathering heroes, and the ultimate edible hug. No fancy techniques, no obscure ingredients – just pure, uncomplicated joy baked into every bite. So grab your favorite mixing bowl (and maybe an apron if you’re as messy as I am), preheat that oven, and let’s turn your kitchen into the coziest bakery in town. Ready to make some memories (and maybe fight over the last cookie)? Let’s do this!

The Cookie That Started a Family Tradition (And a Minor Kitchen Fire)

Print

Okay, story time! These cinnamon cookies? They’re baked right into my heart thanks to my Gram. Every Christmas, her tiny kitchen would transform into a cinnamon-scented wonderland. One particularly chaotic year (I was maybe 12?), I was determined to “help.” Flour flew everywhere, I may have tripled the cinnamon by accident (whoops!), and in my over-enthusiastic sugar-rolling, I knocked over a measuring cup… right onto the stovetop burner. Cue a very minor, very dramatic sugar-smoke situation! Gram, bless her, didn’t panic. She just calmly turned off the burner, opened a window, handed me a new spoon, and said, “Mason, honey, good cookies – like good stories – sometimes need a little extra flavor… and ventilation.” Those imperfect, slightly charred-around-the-edges cookies were the best I’d ever tasted. They tasted like love, laughter, and the comforting truth that kitchen messes often lead to the most delicious memories. Baking these now always brings back that warm, fuzzy feeling (minus the smoke alarm this time, promise!). They’re my edible tribute to Gram’s patience and the magic of embracing the beautiful chaos of baking.

🛒 Your Cinnamon Cookie Toolkit (Let’s Gather the Goods!)

Don’t sweat the double batch! We’re making memories (and leftovers… if they last). Here’s your flavor arsenal:

• Filling:
  • 12 tbsp (1½ sticks) salted butter, softened – Chef’s tip: Softened, NOT melted! Should dent easily when pressed. No salted butter? Use unsalted + ¼ tsp extra salt.
  • 1½ cups brown sugar (packed) – Why brown? Molasses = deep flavor & that dreamy gooeyness. Pack it tight!
  • 3 tbsp cinnamon – Insider move: Use the GOOD stuff. Freshly ground if possible. This is the star!
• Dough:
  • 2 cups salted butter (4 sticks), softened – Double the butter, double the joy. Again, softened is key for creaming.
  • 3⅓ cups granulated sugar – Sweetness backbone. Don’t reduce or texture changes!
  • 4 large eggs – Room temp eggs blend smoother! Pop ’em in warm water for 5 mins if cold.
  • 4 tsp vanilla extract – Pure vanilla only, friends! Imitation just can’t compete.
  • 7 cups all-purpose flour – Fluff & measure! Spoon flour into cup & level off. Don’t scoop from the bag!
  • 2 tsp baking soda – Lift master. Ensure it’s fresh (test with vinegar if unsure!).
  • 1½ tsp kosher salt – Flavor balancer. If using table salt, reduce to 1 tsp.
  • 3 tsp cream of tartar – Secret weapon! Creates that signature chew & tang. Crucial for texture!
• For Rolling:
  • ⅔ cup granulated sugar – The sparkly coat!
  • 3 tbsp cinnamon – More cinnamon? Always. Mix well with the sugar!

👩‍🍳 Let’s Bake! Your Foolproof Cookie Adventure

Put on some tunes, clear some counter space, and let’s roll (literally)!

1. Cream Butter & Sugars (Dance Party Time!): In your largest bowl (trust me, double batch = big bowl!), beat the 2 cups softened butter and 3⅓ cups granulated sugar with an electric mixer on medium-high for 3-4 minutes. Chef’s Hack: Scrape the bowl sides halfway! You want it super light, fluffy, and almost pale. This incorporates air = lighter cookies! Why active voice? Because WE are making magic happen!
2. Egg-cellent Addition: Beat in the 4 eggs, one at a time, letting each fully incorporate before adding the next. Then beat in the 4 tsp vanilla. Pro Tip: Room temp eggs prevent the mix from seizing! Should look smooth and glossy.
3. Dry Team Assemble: In a separate giant bowl (or just rinse and dry your first one!), whisk together the 7 cups flour, 2 tsp baking soda, 1½ tsp kosher salt, and 3 tsp cream of tartar. Insight: Whisking = no baking soda lumps = even rise!
4. The Grand Merge (Low & Slow Wins): Gradually add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture, mixing on LOW speed just until combined after each addition. CRUCIAL TIP: Overmixing = tough cookies! Stop when no dry flour remains. Dough will be thick.
5. Make That Luscious Filling: In a medium bowl, mash together the 12 tbsp softened butter, 1½ cups packed brown sugar, and 3 tbsp cinnamon until it forms a thick, spreadable paste. Chef’s Flavor Boost: Taste it! Want more cinnamon? Go for it!
6. Scoop, Flatten, Fill, Seal (Cookie Pillows!): Scoop dough using a medium cookie scoop (about 1.5 tbsp). Roll into a ball, then flatten slightly in your palm. Place a heaping teaspoon (about ¾ tsp) of filling in the center. Carefully fold the dough edges up and over the filling, pinching to seal completely. Roll gently between palms to smooth. Hack Alert: If filling oozes, a tiny dusting of flour on your fingers helps seal it!
7. Cinnamon Sugar Hug: Roll each sealed dough ball generously in the cinnamon-sugar mixture. Place 2 inches apart on parchment-lined baking sheets. Why parchment? Prevents sticking AND makes cleanup a breeze!
8. Bake to Golden Perfection: Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 10-12 minutes. Watch closely! They’re done when the edges are set and golden, but the centers still look slightly soft and puffy. DO NOT OVERBAKE! This is the secret to chewiness.
9. The Patient Wait (I Know, It’s Hard!): Let cookies cool on the baking sheet for 5 minutes. Science Bit: They keep cooking from residual heat! Then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely. Resisting the urge to eat one now builds character… mostly.

☕ Serving Up the Cozy

Warm cookies + cold milk = pure bliss. Serve these beauties slightly warm (microwave for 5-8 seconds if needed!) for that irresistible gooey center. Pile them high on a rustic wooden board for gatherings, or sneak a few onto a plate for solo indulgence. They’re heavenly alongside a steaming mug of coffee for breakfast (no judgment here!) or as the star of a dessert spread with vanilla ice cream for an epic cookie sundae. Basically, anywhere, anytime, with anyone (or just for you!).

✨ Mix It Up! Your Cookie, Your Rules

Love the base? Let’s play!

• Apple Pie Twist: Add 1 tsp apple pie spice to the filling + fold ½ cup finely chopped dried apples into the dough.
• Choco-Cinn Swirl: Swap ¼ cup of the cinnamon in the filling for unsweetened cocoa powder. Divine!
• Nutty Crunch: Roll the filled dough balls in chopped pecans or walnuts AFTER the cinnamon sugar coating.
• Gluten-Free Joy: Use a quality 1:1 GF flour blend (like Bob’s Red Mill). Texture might be slightly more delicate.
• Brown Butter Bliss: Brown the butter for the filling first! Cool slightly before mixing. Adds incredible depth.

🧑‍🍳 Mason’s Crumbs (Extra Thoughts from My Kitchen)

This recipe? It’s a living thing! Gram’s original was a single batch, but scaling up was my first “chef” move (driven purely by cookie greed). Over the years, I tweaked the flour ratio for the perfect chew and doubled down on the cinnamon because… well, cinnamon! A funny fail? Once I forgot the cream of tartar. Flat, crispy discs ensued – tasty, but NOT the dream. Lesson learned! These cookies freeze like champs too. Freeze the filled, unbaked dough balls on a sheet, then toss into a bag. Bake straight from frozen, adding 1-2 minutes. Fresh cookies anytime! Remember, baking is about heart, not perfection. If a little filling leaks? It caramelizes into deliciousness. If your kitchen gets dusty with flour? That’s just the mark of a good time. Embrace it!

❓ Cookie Conundrums? Solved!

Let’s tackle those baking hiccups:

• Q: Can I halve this recipe? I don’t need 48 cookies! (Lies!)
  A: You absolutely can! Halve every ingredient precisely. Baking time might be slightly less (start checking at 8 mins). But fair warning… you’ll wish you made the full batch!
• Q: Why are my cookies spreading flat?
  A: Three likely culprits: 1) Butter was too soft/melted – it should be cool to the touch but dentable. 2) Dough was too warm before baking – chill scooped dough for 15-20 mins if your kitchen is hot. 3) Old baking soda/powder – test it! Or 4) Over-creaming the butter/sugar (creates too much air that collapses).
• Q: My filling leaked everywhere! Disaster?
  A: Not at all! It happens, especially if the dough gets warm. Ensure you pinch the seal REALLY well. Leaked filling just creates delicious caramelized bits – embrace the rustic charm! A little flour on your fingers helps seal sticky dough.
• Q: How do I store them to keep them soft?
  A: Let them cool completely! Store in an airtight container at room temp with a slice of bread tossed in. The bread releases moisture keeping the cookies soft for days (up to 5!). Remove soggy bread and replace as needed.

Nutritional Info (Per Cookie – Approximate)

Calories: ~210 | Fat: 10g | Carbohydrates: 28g | Protein: 2g

Remember: This is about joy in every bite! Enjoy responsibly (or not so responsibly, I won’t tell!).

---

Final Thoughts: Warm, Gooey, and Gone Too Fast

There’s something downright magical about these cookies—the way they make your kitchen smell like a cinnamon dream, the gooey surprise in every bite, the “just one more” effect that turns into five. They’re nostalgic, comforting, and ridiculously crave-worthy. Whether you’re baking them for a crowd, for the holidays, or just for yourself (no shame), they deliver every time.

And hey, if a little filling leaks out or your sugar trail leads to the floor, that’s not a fail—it’s flavor in progress. These cookies aren’t about perfection. They’re about memories, messes, and moments that smell like Gram’s kitchen. So roll up your sleeves, preheat that oven, and bake yourself some edible joy. You’ve earned it—twice over.