Ultimate Butterscotch Cake

Hey, Let’s Bake Some Joy!

Picture this: golden-brown layers so tender they practically sigh when you slice them, hugging a cloud of velvety butterscotch frosting, all crowned with a happy avalanche of butterscotch chips. That’s not just dessert, my friend—that’s the Ultimate Butterscotch Cake we’re whipping up today. If your soul does a little happy dance at the thought of rich, caramelized sweetness with zero fuss, you’re in exactly the right spot. This isn’t just a cake; it’s a double-serving, crowd-wowing, memory-making machine. Perfect for birthdays, potlucks, or “just because Tuesdays” that need extra sparkle. I designed this beauty to be BIG on flavor but totally approachable—no pastry degree required. We’re talking moist crumb? Check. Insane butterscotch flavor in every bite? Double-check. That “wow” factor when you bring it to the table? Oh yeah. So tie on your favorite apron, crank up your kitchen playlist, and let’s turn simple ingredients into pure, uncomplicated magic. Trust me, your people are gonna lose their minds over this one. Ready to bake some joy?

Why Butterscotch? A Sweet Slice of Nostalgia

Print

Butterscotch always takes me straight back to my grandma’s linoleum-floored kitchen. She’d keep a jar of those hard butterscotch candies on her counter—the kind wrapped in crinkly gold foil. I’d sneak them after school while she told stories about her childhood in Kentucky, the sweet-buttery taste melting on my tongue. Fast-forward to my first big dinner party as a “real adult.” I wanted to impress, so I tried making her famous butterscotch sauce. Let’s just say… I learned caramel can go from golden to charcoal in 10 seconds flat. Smoke alarm serenade included. But that fail sparked something! I became obsessed with nailing that deep, toasty flavor without the stress. This cake? It’s my love letter to Grandma’s candy jar and that slightly smoky kitchen disaster. It’s the cozy nostalgia of butterscotch, reimagined as a showstopping, shareable celebration. Every time I bake it, I swear I catch a whiff of her lilac perfume. And zero smoke alarms!

Gather Your Flavor Squad

Here’s the dream team! Don’t sweat substitutions—I’ve got backup ideas.

Butterscotch Cake

• 5 cups (650g) all-purpose flour: Our trusty foundation. Want extra-tender cake? Swap 1 cup for cake flour! (Chef insight: Spoon & level it—don’t scoop from the bag or you’ll pack in too much!)
• 6.8 oz butterscotch instant pudding mix (2 boxes): The SECRET for insane moisture & flavor depth! (Sub: Vanilla pudding + 1 tsp butter extract in a pinch, but butterscotch is magic here.)
• 7 tsp baking powder: Our lift-off crew. Check the expiry date—old powder won’t puff properly!
• 1 tsp salt: Balances the sweet. Use fine sea salt or table salt.
• 1 1/2 cups (336g) unsalted butter, room temp: Soft = creamy bliss. (Hack: Cubes soften faster! Sub: Salted butter? Just omit the added salt.)
• 3 cups (674g) packed light brown sugar: Deep molasses notes = butterscotch soul. Pack it tight! Dark brown sugar works for extra richness.
• 6 tbsp vegetable oil: Guarantees that melt-in-your-mouth crumb. Neutral oils like canola or grapeseed work too.
• 2 tsp vanilla extract: Flavor enhancer. Pure extract > imitation!
• 8 large eggs: Room temp eggs blend smoother. (Quick warm-up: Place cold eggs in warm water for 5 mins.)
• 2 1/2 cups (600ml) milk: Whole milk = best richness. (Sub: Buttermilk for subtle tang, or any dairy-free milk.)

Butterscotch Frosting

• 2 1/2 cups (560g) unsalted butter, room temp: Pillowy base. Seriously, room temp is non-negotiable!
• 22 oz butterscotch chips, melted: The FLAVOR BOMB. Melt slowly to avoid seizing. (Chef tip: Use a double boiler or microwave in 20-sec bursts, stirring!)
• 12 1/2 cups (1,438g) powdered sugar: Sweetness & structure. Sift it to avoid lumps!
• 1 tsp salt: Cuts the sweet, makes flavors pop.
• 1 cup (240ml) milk or cream: Cream = extra lush. Milk = still great! Adjust for your perfect spreadable texture.

Additional

• 24–28 oz butterscotch chips: The glitter on our masterpiece! Press ’em gently onto the sides & pile high on top.

Let’s Build Some Cake Magic: Step-by-Step

Channel your inner cake boss! We’ve got this.

1. Preheat & Prep: “Crank that oven to 350°F (175°C). Pro Tip: Use an oven thermometer! Most ovens lie. Grease and flour two deep 9-inch round pans (or four if splitting layers later). (Hack: Trace parchment paper on pan bottoms for foolproof release!)
2. Dry Team Unite: “In a big bowl, whisk together your flour, butterscotch pudding mix, baking powder, and salt. Why whisk? No one wants a baking powder pocket explosion! Set this golden crew aside.
3. Creamy Dreams: “In your largest bowl (trust me, you’ll need space!), beat the softened butter and packed brown sugar on medium-high for 4-5 minutes. Watch for the magic: It should look super fluffy and pale. (No shortcutting! This creates air pockets for lift.) Add oil and vanilla, beat another minute until silky.
4. Egg-cellent Addition: “Add eggs ONE at a time, beating well after each (about 30 seconds per egg). Why one-by-one? Prevents curdling and ensures each egg gets cozy with the butter. Scrape the bowl halfway—stray egg whites are party poopers.
5. The Gentle Merge: “Time to marry wet & dry! Add 1/3 of the flour mix, beat on low just until combined. Follow with 1/2 the milk, mixing gently. Repeat: flour, milk, ending with flour. KEY TIP: DO NOT OVERMIX! Stop the second the flour disappears. Overmixing = tough cake. Lumps are okay—they’ll vanish while baking.
6. Pan & Bake: “Divide batter evenly between pans (a kitchen scale is handy here!). Smooth tops. Bake 25-30 minutes. Doneness Test: A toothpick in the center should come out with moist crumbs, not wet batter. (Rotate pans halfway for even baking!) Cool in pans 10 mins, then flip onto wire racks to cool COMPLETELY. Patience, Padawan: Frosting a warm cake = melty disaster.
7. Frosting Finesse: “Beat butter until smooth & creamy (2 mins). Slowly drizzle in COOLED melted butterscotch chips while beating. Gradually add powdered sugar and salt. Beat on low first to avoid a sugar cloud! Add milk/cream 1 tbsp at a time until spreadable. Beat 3-4 mins on medium-high until outrageously fluffy. Texture Check: Should hold a peak but spread easily. Too thick? Add cream. Too thin? Add powdered sugar.
8. Assembly Joy: “Level cake layers if needed (a serrated knife works). Place a dollop of frosting on your cake board/plate to anchor the bottom layer. Frost between layers, then do a thin “crumb coat” over the whole cake. Chill 15 mins (locks in crumbs!), then pile on the rest of the frosting. Swirl it, smooth it—get artsy! Generously press butterscotch chips onto sides and heap them gloriously on top. Final Boss Tip: Use a bench scraper for smooth sides!

Serving Up the Sweet Victory

This beauty deserves a moment! Place it on a cake stand or simple plate—its golden chips are bling enough. For extra drama, drizzle slices with warm caramel sauce or add a dollop of barely-sweetened whipped cream. Cutting Hack: Use a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped clean between slices for pristine layers. Serve with big smiles and bigger napkins! It’s rich, so smaller slices go a long way (though seconds are highly encouraged).

Mix It Up! Your Cake, Your Rules

Love the base but wanna play? Here’s how to riff:

• Salted Caramel Swirl: Swirl 1 cup thick salted caramel sauce between layers & sprinkle flaky sea salt on top frosting.
• Nutty Buddy: Fold 1 cup toasted chopped pecans or walnuts into the batter & sprinkle on top with the chips.
• Choco-Scotch Dream: Swap 3/4 cup flour for cocoa powder in the cake layers. Use chocolate chips in the frosting or for decoration!
• Boozy Bliss: Brush cooled cake layers with 1/4 cup bourbon or dark rum before frosting. *chef’s kiss*
• Dairy-Free/Gluten-Free: Use plant-based butter & milk (soy or oat work well). Swap flour for a 1:1 GF blend + 1 tsp xanthan gum. Ensure pudding mix & chips are DF/GF.

From My Kitchen to Yours: Extra Sprinkles of Wisdom

This cake has seen some things! Remember my “Great Butterscotch Chip Avalanche of ‘22”? I was decorating, got distracted by my dog doing zoomies, and accidentally knocked the entire bowl of chips… mostly onto the floor. My solution? I called it “deconstructed butterscotch crunch” and served it with extra frosting for dipping. Total hit! Over the years, I’ve tweaked it—adding the pudding mix was a revelation (thank you, 3 a.m. baking experiments!), and using oil *with* butter guarantees that perfect moistness that lasts days. It’s become my go-to for feeding a crowd without stress. The best part? It actually gets MORE flavorful overnight as the butterscotch magic soaks in. So if you can resist, bake it a day ahead! Just frost day-of. Most importantly? Have fun. Burned a layer? Trifle it! Frosting a mess? More chips hide everything. Cooking is connection, remember? Imperfections are just extra flavor stories.

Final Thoughts:

There’s something undeniably magical about butterscotch—it’s like the cozy sweater of the dessert world. This Butterscotch Cake brings all that warm, buttery comfort in every slice, whether you’re baking it for a holiday gathering, a birthday, or just because Tuesday needed a little glow-up. Don’t stress the swirl or the crumb; this cake is all about joy, indulgence, and maybe licking the frosting spoon when no one’s looking. Trust your taste buds, take your time, and let the scent of bubbling butterscotch fill your kitchen with sweet anticipation. You’ve got this—and your fork is about to be very, very happy.